Fault-finding
Most breakdowns on boats are small causes with big effects: a blocked filter, a loose wire, a worn , air in the fuel. The skipper who finds them quickly is not the one who knows the most about engines, but the one who works in order. Panic, random part-swapping and "it was fine yesterday" waste hours; a method finds the fault.
The method
- Make the boat safe first. Anchor, , sail away from danger or get a tow. A fault diagnosed in a calm is found faster than one chased while drifting onto rocks.
- Describe the symptom exactly. Not "the engine stopped" but "the engine slowed and stopped after ten minutes at high revs, and restarts but stops again".
- Ask what changed. New fuel, a filter just changed, a long period unused, rough weather that stirred the tank, work done by someone. The last change is the first suspect.
- Check the simplest causes first: is it switched on, is there fuel, water, power, is the open, is the kill cord in, is it in neutral?
- Follow the system from the source: fuel from the tank to the injector, water from the seacock to the exhaust, power from the battery to the device. Test each step; do not guess.
- Change one thing at a time, and note what you did. Two changes at once and you never know which one worked.
- Write it in the log: the symptom, the cause, the fix, and the part to replace properly later.
The engine will not start
- Nothing happens when you turn the key: battery switch, engine battery voltage (a healthy resting 12 V battery reads about 12.6 V; under 12 V it is close to flat), the main fuse, the start relay, the neutral safety switch, corroded terminals. A starter motor that clicks but does not turn: low voltage or a bad connection before you blame the starter.
- It turns but will not fire: fuel (tank empty, valve shut, blocked filter, air in the fuel after a filter change: bleed it from the filter to the injection pump as the manual says), the fuel stop solenoid, or for a cold diesel the glow plugs. Water in the fuel shows in the filter bowl.
- It fires and stops: fuel starvation (a partly blocked filter or tank pickup, a pinched hose, a blocked tank vent), or air being drawn in at a loose fitting.
The engine overheats
- Look at the exhaust first: is cooling water coming out with the gas? No water means a raw water problem.
- Raw water side: seacock open, strainer clean (weed, plastic bags, jellyfish), impeller intact (a failed impeller sheds blades into the heat exchanger: find every piece), the pump belt, a blocked intake on the hull.
- Fresh water side: coolant level (check only when cool), the thermostat, the circulation pump and its belt, a clogged heat exchanger (scale and old impeller pieces).
- Overheating after hours at high revs in warm water often means a heat exchanger or exhaust elbow partly blocked with scale; it gets worse gradually, so note the temperature in the log.
- Stop the engine before damage: an overheated diesel can damage the head gasket, and the rubber exhaust hose can burn through and let water into the boat.
Smoke and loss of power
- Black smoke: not enough air or too much fuel: a dirty air filter, an overloaded engine (a fouled propeller or bottom, a rope round the prop, the wrong propeller), or a faulty injector.
- White smoke that does not clear when warm: water in the cylinders or in the fuel, a head gasket, or a cracked exhaust elbow. A little white vapour when cold is normal.
- Blue smoke: the engine is burning oil: worn rings or valve guides, or too much oil in the sump.
- Loses power: a fouled propeller or rope round it (look over the side), a blocked fuel filter (the most common cause, after rough weather stirs the tank), a blocked air intake, or an overheating engine that has gone into a protection mode.
Electrics: no charge, flat batteries, a dead circuit
- Batteries flat in the morning: measure the resting voltage, then switch off everything and watch for a current draw (a clamp meter on the main cable shows it): a fridge, a stuck pump, an instrument left on, a leaking connection.
- No charge from the engine: the alternator belt, the field wire and the main output cable, the regulator, the battery switch position. With the engine running, the battery should read clearly above resting voltage (often 13.8 to 14.4 V for lead-acid).
- No charge from solar: the panel in shade, a blown fuse, the controller's settings and its display.
- A dead circuit: the breaker or fuse, then voltage at the device with the multimeter, then the negative return (a bad earth is as common as a bad supply). Salt and damp corrode terminals: clean, crimp properly and protect.
Water in the boat
- Is it fresh or salt? Taste it (a drop). Fresh: the water tanks, pump or a hose. Salt: the sea is getting in.
- Is it rising? Start the pumps, then search from the lowest point: through-hulls and their hoses, the shaft seal, the rudder seal, the cockpit drains, the engine raw water circuit and the exhaust, the heads hoses, the log and depth transducers, a sail-drive seal.
- Dry the bilge with a sponge and watch where the water comes from. A torch along every hose finds a weep fast.
- A tapered soft wooden plug at every through-hull, tied to it, turns a broken seacock into a minor event.
Steering, autopilot, watermaker, outboard
- Steering stiff or slack: cables or hydraulic fluid, the quadrant bolts, the rudder bearings. Know where your emergency fits and practise with it before you need it.
- Autopilot: most faults are the power supply (voltage drop on long thin cables), the compass sensor near iron or a speaker, or a slipping clutch or drive. Check the connections before you replace the brain.
- : low output with good pressure usually means a fouled membrane or cold water; no pressure means the pump, a blocked pre-filter or air in the feed. Never run it in a harbour or near a river mouth: oil and silt ruin membranes.
- : kill cord in, fuel tank vent open, primer bulb firm, fresh fuel (old fuel is the first cause of a dead outboard), a clean spark plug, a water stream from the tell-tale when running.
What to carry to diagnose and fix
- A multimeter and a clamp meter (for DC current), and the knowledge to use them.
- A good head torch and a mirror on a stick.
- The manuals and wiring diagrams on paper, and a parts list with the numbers.
- Spare impellers (more than one), fuel filters, oil filter, belts, a thermostat, hose clamps, a length of each hose size, fuses of every size used, crimp terminals and a ratchet crimper, self-amalgamating tape, epoxy putty.
- A bleeding kit for the fuel system and a container to catch fuel.
- Notes of your own normal readings: oil pressure, temperature, charging voltage, fuel use at your usual revs. A fault is easiest to see as a change from normal.
Seasonal timing
- Northern temperate waters
- Change filters and impellers in the lay-up months, not the day before the first passage.
- Southern temperate waters
- The same, before the southern season.
- The tropics
- In the tropics, before the season starts and again halfway: heat, growth and dust wear things faster.
Tips from experience
- Write your engine's normal temperature, oil pressure and charging voltage on a card by the instruments.
- After changing a fuel filter, run the engine at the dock for 20 minutes before going to sea.
- Take a photo of every wiring connection before you undo it.
- Keep one spare of everything that stops the boat if it fails: impeller, fuel filter, belt, starter relay, autopilot drive belt.
- Fuel problems come after rough weather: change the filter when the weather has stirred the tank, before it blocks.
- Label every hose and wire you add, at both ends.
- Learn to bleed your engine's fuel system at the dock, in daylight, before you have to do it at sea.
- A small inspection camera on a phone sees behind the engine where your eyes cannot.
- Listen to your boat: a new noise, a new smell or a new vibration is the first symptom.
What it usually costs depends on
- Whether you can diagnose yourself or must call someone out.
- Where you are (a remote island versus a busy yard).
- Whether the part is in stock or must be shipped, and the import paperwork.
- Whether a small cause was left until it made a big one.
Ask for written quotes locally: prices differ a great deal between countries, harbours and seasons.
Common mistakes, and the lesson from each
- ❌ Swapping parts at random. Each change costs money and hides the real cause. Test, then replace.
- ❌ Changing two things at once. You never learn which one fixed it. One change at a time.
- ❌ Ignoring the last thing that changed. A fault after a filter change, a refuel or someone's work is usually that change.
- ❌ Running an overheating engine "to get home". A blown gasket or a burnt exhaust hose turns a cheap repair into a big one. Stop, sail, fix.
- ❌ Not checking the exhaust water when starting. Look every time. No water at the exhaust in the first minute means stop.
- ❌ Losing the pieces of a failed impeller. They block the heat exchanger. Count the blades and find them all.
- ❌ Blaming the battery when the connection is bad. Measure at the device and at the battery; corrosion and loose terminals cause most electrical faults.
- ❌ No spare impeller or fuel filter on board. They stop the boat more often than anything. Carry two.
- ❌ Never having tried the emergency tiller. Fit it once at the dock. Then you know it fits and how it steers.
- ❌ Old fuel in the outboard. Old petrol is the first cause of a dead outboard. Use fresh fuel and run the carburettor dry before storing.
Go deeper
- Breakdowns at sea and at anchor
- Engine care
- Electrics and batteries
- Engine cooling guide
- Electrical systems and battery guide
- Fresh water plumbing guide
- Battery and solar budget
- Cable size and voltage drop
- Emergency card
← The Skipper's Handbook · ‹ The rules that apply to a yacht · Marina culture and sea courtesy ›
General guidance from experience, not instructions for your boat: follow the maker's manuals and ask a qualified professional for work you are not sure of.